| NYSSWA 1st Team All-State Selections | ||||
| * - Player of the Year | ||||
| ** - Co-Player of the Year | ||||
| 2025-26 | 1999-2000 | |||
| Class AA | Class B | |||
| Michael Cascione | Smithtown West | Joel Suarez | St. Mary's | |
| Class B | Courtney Pritchard | Southampton | ||
| Ryan Leary | Carle Place | Bill Kretz | Amityville | |
| Class D | Class C | |||
| Jai Feaster | Bridgehampton | Tamien Trent | Center Moriches | |
| 2024-25 | 1998-99 | |||
| Class A | Class A | |||
| Alex Franklin | Southampton | Drew Nicholas | LuHi | |
| Dominic Pennzello | Mount Sinai | Class B | ||
| Class B | Joel Suarez | St. Mary's | ||
| Ryan Leary | Carle Place | Courtney Pritchard | Southampton | |
| Class D | Brian Werner | Chaminade | ||
| Lorenzo Crilly | Smithtown Christian | Class C | ||
| Andwele Murray | LWA | |||
| 2023-24 | Class D | |||
| Class AAA | Ron White | Bridgehampton | ||
| V.J. Edgecombe | LuHi | |||
| Class AA | 1997-98 | |||
| Cassius Moore | Elmont | Class B | ||
| Jagger Bascombe | St. Mary's | Sean Kennedy | St. Dominic | |
| Class D | Dale Menendez | Westhampton | ||
| Isaiah McCarter | Smithtown Christian | Jermaine Hollman | Westhampton | |
| Class D | ||||
| 2022-23 | Maurice Manning | Bridgehampton | ||
| Class AA | Ron White | Bridgehampton | ||
| *Jayden Reid | LuHi | |||
| V.J. Edgecombe | LuHi | 1996-97 | ||
| Class B | Class B | |||
| Derek Reed | Southampton | Jim Moran | St. Dominic | |
| Class D | ||||
| 2021-22 | Maurice Manning | Bridgehampton | ||
| Class AA | ||||
| Jayden Reid | LuHi | 1995-96 | ||
| Class A | Class A | |||
| Ryan Weiss | Hewlett | Vassil Evtimov | LuHi | |
| Class B | Class B | |||
| *Zaire Baines | Portledge | Jason Hernandez | St. Dominic | |
| Class C | Class D | |||
| Wilson Bennett | Pierson | Terrell Hopson | Bridgehampton | |
| Maurice Manning | Bridgehampton | |||
| 2020-21 | ||||
| No Teams Selected | 1994-95 | |||
| Class B | ||||
| 2019-20 | Stan Martin | Westbury | ||
| Class AA | Class C | |||
| **Andre Curbelo | LuHi | Wally Szczerbiak | Cold Spring Harbor | |
| Zed Key | LuHi | |||
| Jordan Reilly | Brentwood | 1993-94 | ||
| Class A | Class A | |||
| Andre Snoddy | St. Anthony's | Bob Hodgson | William Floyd | |
| Class B | Class B | |||
| *Ahkee Anderson | Center Moriches | Zendon Hamilton | Sewanhaka | |
| 2018-19 | 1992-93 | |||
| Class AA | Class B | |||
| **Andre Curbelo | LuHi | Zendon Hamilton | Sewanhaka | |
| Class A | Class C | |||
| Michael O'Connell | Chaminade | Brad Cirino | Wheatley | |
| Class B | ||||
| Aiden Igiehon | LWA | 1991-92 | ||
| Class C | Class B | |||
| Ahkee Anderson | Greenport | Joe Joyner | Amityville | |
| Zendon Hamilton | Sewanhaka | |||
| 2017-18 | ||||
| Class AA | 1990-91 | |||
| *Savion Lewis | Hills East | Class B | ||
| Class A | Shawn Abercrombie | Manhasset | ||
| Andrew DeSantis | Garden City | David Mascia | Lynbrook | |
| Josh Serrano | Amityville | |||
| Class B | 1989-90 | |||
| Aiden Igiehon | LWA | Class B | ||
| Class C | Will Brown | Miller Place | ||
| Ahkee Anderson | Greenport | Class C-D | ||
| Bob Hopson | Bridgehampton | |||
| 2016-17 | ||||
| Class AA | 1988-89 | |||
| Savion Lewis | Hills East | Class B | ||
| Class A | Ken Wood | East Hampton | ||
| Kashawn Charles | Wyandanch | |||
| Class B | 1986-87 | |||
| Jordan Dingle | LWA | Small Schools | ||
| Troy Bowe | Bridgehampton | |||
| 2015-16 | Bob Gordon | Manhasset | ||
| Class AA | ||||
| Jamel Allen | Brentwood | 1985-86 | ||
| Devonte Green | LuHi | Large Schools | ||
| Class A | Tom Greis | St. Anthony's | ||
| Steve Torre | Kellenberg | Small Schools | ||
| George Robinson | Manhasset | |||
| 2014-15 | ||||
| Class AA | 1984-85 | |||
| Jamel Allen | Brentwood | Small Schools | ||
| Devonte Green | LuHi | John Ward | Center Moriches | |
| Class D | Derald Preston | Friends Academy | ||
| *Charles Manning Jr. | Bridgehampton | Juliam Johnson | Bridgehampton | |
| Josh Lamison | Bridgehampton | |||
| 1983-84 | ||||
| 2012-13 | Large Schools | |||
| Class AA | Shelton Jones | Amityville | ||
| Luke Petrasek | Northport | Small Schools | ||
| Kentan Facey | LuHi | Rod Harris | Bridgehampton | |
| Class B | Matt Ryan | Miller Place | ||
| Fernando Vasquez | Babylon | |||
| Class D | 1982-83 | |||
| Jason Hopson | Bridgehampton | Large Schools | ||
| Russell Pierre | North Babylon | |||
| 2011-12 | Augusto Binelli | LuHi | ||
| Class A | Small Schools | |||
| Lucas Woodhouse | Harborfields | Dinky Miller | East Hampton | |
| Matt Ryan | Miller Place | |||
| 2010-11 | ||||
| Class AA | 1981-82 | |||
| Tavon Sledge | Hills West | Large Schools | ||
| Class A | Alex Agudio | Whitman | ||
| *Achraf Yacoubou | LuHi | Tim Kempton | St. Dominic | |
| Chauvaugh Lewis | St. Mary's | Small Schools | ||
| Class C | Kevin Read | Miller Place | ||
| Dantre Langhorne | Greenport | |||
| 1980-81 | ||||
| 2009-10 | Large Schools | |||
| Class AA | AndrewHawkins | Malverne | ||
| *Tobias Harris | Hills West | Bill Wennington | LuHi | |
| Class A | ||||
| Achraf Yacoubou | LuHi | 1979-80 | ||
| Class D | Large Schools | |||
| Dantre Langhorne | Greenport | Bret Bearup | Harborfields | |
| Wes Correa | Bellport | |||
| 2008-09 | Matt Doherty | Holy Trinity | ||
| Class A | Small Schools | |||
| Tobias Harris | LuHi | Carl Johnson | Bridgehampton | |
| Class B | ||||
| Devin Karch | Locust Valley | 1978-79 | ||
| Class C | Large Schools | |||
| John Nielson | Port Jefferson | Tom Emma | Manhasset | |
| Class D | David Russell | Bellport | ||
| Ryan Creighton | Greenport | Small Schools | ||
| Wally Sorenson | Greenport | Don Wilcenski | Mattituck | |
| 2007-08 | 1977-78 | |||
| Class A | Large Schools | |||
| Mike Russell | East Hampton | Tom Emma | Manhasset | |
| Class B | Rory Glasco | West Babylon | ||
| Rob Ptacek | Bayport BP | |||
| Class D | 1976-77 | |||
| Ryan Creighton | Greenport | Large Schools | ||
| Wayne McKoy | LuHi | |||
| 2006-07 | Jeff Ruland | Sachem | ||
| Class A | Stan Wilcox | North Babylon | ||
| Prentice Small | St. John The Baptist | |||
| Class B | 1975-76 | |||
| Craig Wilson | Malverne | Large Schools | ||
| Chris Barber | Wyandanch | Jim Graziano | Farmingdale | |
| Greg Lott | Malverne | Wayne McKoy | LuHi | |
| Class D | Glenn Vickers | Babylon | ||
| Ryan Creighton | Greenport | |||
| 1974-75 | ||||
| 2005-06 | Large Schools | |||
| Class A | Reggie Carter | LuHi | ||
| Tyrone Nash | LWA | Jim Graziano | Farmingdale | |
| Wayne McKoy | LuHi | |||
| 2004-05 | Mike Palma | St. Agnes | ||
| Class AA | ||||
| Danny Green | St. Mary's | 1973-74 | ||
| Class A | Large Schools | |||
| Tom Leszczynski | St. Anthony's | Tom Hicks | St. Anthony's | |
| Class D | Small Schools | |||
| Chris Evangelista | Shelter Island | Gordon Johnson | Bridgehampton | |
| Matt Fay | Seton Hall | |||
| 2003-04 | ||||
| Class AA | 1972-73 | |||
| A.J. Price | Amityville | Large Schools | ||
| Class B | John Pitts | Hempstead | ||
| Darrell Wonge | Malverne | |||
| 1971-72 | ||||
| 2002-03 | Large Schools | |||
| Class B | Frank Alagia | St. Agnes | ||
| A.J. Price | Amityville | |||
| Dan Nawrocki | Chaminade | 1969-70 | ||
| Kenny Jones | Wyandanch | Dennis DuVal | Westbury | |
| 2001-02 | 1968-69 | |||
| Class B | Bill Kunze | LuHi | ||
| Mamadou Diakhate | St. Mary's | |||
| Tim Doyle | St. Dominic | 1967-68 | ||
| Jason Fraser | Amityville | Bill Chamberlain | LuHi | |
| Class C | Tom Riker | St. Dominic | ||
| Carl Benn | LWA | |||
| Jacob Clark | Port Jefferson | |||
| Class D | ||||
| Gerald Crenshaw | Greenport | |||
| 2000-01 | ||||
| Class B | ||||
| Tristan Smith | Amityville | |||
| Jason Fraser | Amityville | |||
| Class D | ||||
| Gerald Crenshaw | Greenport | |||
| Daryl Fishburne | Bridgehampton | |||